"As I demonstrate below, Katz’s research is sloppy at best, and negligent at worst..."
This is incorrect, and dangerously so. Katz's "research" is not research, not sloppy, and not negligent. It is intentional gaslighting propaganda presented on behalf of the global Establishment in an effort to create a world in which there are no online spaces where wrongthink is allowed to flourish. He is a propagandist, not a researcher. His "research" is no more "sloppy" or "negligent" than is the "research" of Joseph Goebbels.
I don't know if he is a paid agent carrying out orders or just a fierce Establishment loyalist acting on his own volition, but he serves the same purpose either way. There is an army of these people with the self-righteousness and certitude of the Red Guard, and their objective is nothing less than the complete elimination of public dissent. There is no good faith explanation for the gaping chasm between Katz's argument and the evidence you quite skillfully present in this piece. These people do not deserve the benefit of any doubt. The overly charitable interpretation you give to Katz's propaganda efforts will not be reciprocated. The title should read "The Atlantic has a gaslighting and propaganda problem."
“They are, all of them, born with raging fanaticism in their hearts, just as the Bretons and the Germans are born with blonde hair, I would not be in the least bit surprised if these people would not become deadly to the human race. They have surpassed all nations in impertinent fables, in bad conduct and in barbarism. They deserve to be punished, for this is their destiny. The Jewish nation dares to display an irreconcilable hatred towards all nations, and revolts against all masters; always superstitious, always greedy for the well-being enjoyed by others, always barbarous; cringing in misfortune and insolent in prosperity.”
“You shall put all of the males to the sword. You may, however, take as your booty the women, the children and the livestock, and everything in the town – all of its spoil – and enjoy the use of the spoil of your enemy which the Lord gives unto you.” — Deuteronomy 20:13
-
“The Messenger said, ‘If the disbelievers do not accept Islam, kill them, loot them and rape their women.’ And thus, advance Islam and strengthen Islam.” — Al-Bukhaari, Vol. 4, Book 54, Hadith 464
Ian-- nice work. I suspect that you and I aren’t literally in the same lane politically, but I point that out to make it clear that whatever the truth of that, tactics like JK’s shouldn’t be praised or admired. And I’m very impressed by the work you put into this.
My position, for what it’s worth-- there’s enough actual evidence for someone to be outraged about the platform, if they’re inclined. It’s far less than JK implies, and I do think innuendo is the right word here. I feel like he’s in the neighborhood of Roy Cohn here, a neighborhood I would prefer the left avoid entirely.
He seems now to be saying that he’s not actually arguing for kicking people off the platform at all, and possibly he means it. I’ll give him the benefit of the doubt that he doesn’t give to substack or Hanania.
But I’ve seen a lot of posts calling for people to be deplatformed, and while there’s a range of positions on that side, mostly I see people trying to thread a needle that can’t be threaded, like this: “this isn’t a free speech issue. Nazis shouldn’t have free speech.”
I don’t object to anyone leaving substack on principle over this; it seems to me that they could make that call with the actual true evidence rather than the gilded lily version JK offers. I hope they won’t leave over it, but if they do i wish them well. I respect people who make a principled stand, even if I don’t share their view. I don’t respect people who profit from grandstanding. He’s misled a lot of good people, as I see it.
He has said that he can’t afford to leave substack. So this means he’s smearing the substack people with undefended innuendo, while risking not one cent of the money he makes from their policies.
In the end, I assume a lot of people will get tired of beating this horse and get back to beating the horse I preferred to see beaten, the issue of antisemitism creeping into progressive orthodoxy. I don’t know if JK has condemned that; in my view that’s a real problem, and the Nazis-on-substack problem doesn’t compare.
To be sure, there’s not much in the way of explicit calls to deplatform; that, I’ll give to Katz. And his basic premise is not badly founded, because he would find much succour among the Substack lay populace if it were teeming with Nazis.
But I find his case severely lacking, being full of holes such as it is; certainly not enough to warrant the scathing ad hominems he’s been throwing around with profligate impunity as well as the incessant badgering for the Substack brass to cede to his demand for a sit-down, which I’m sure he would not carry out honestly.
I’m not concerned at all with disagreements over politics; believe me. Just about everyone who has been giving me praise (and I thank them) for these posts is farther to the political right than I am, but at the same time, I sympathize with them, because at this moment in history, it’s the Left that are driving *them* into corners rather than the other way around, and a tired tactic I hear over and over is to associate libertarians and conservatives with Nazis, which is a low move.
Now, you can point to the much more murderous Communist regimes of Stalin, Mao, and Pol Pot (all of whom acted in a manner indistinguishable from despotism) as a like salvo against the political left (that would be just as wrong), but that fails to work for one reason: Communism isn’t associated with ethnic cleansing like Nazism.
I conclude from this that the critical left in the West thinks that identitarian concerns trump lives lost altogether, which calls into question why we let them dominate so many aspects of daily life, from media and entertainment to scholastics and PR to the virulent and voracious campaigns to mow down collateral under the overt auspices of “hunting down Nazis” while never answering questions about why they don’t go after more prominent threats.
In this sense, though I don’t agree with their policies, personally, I think conservatives are fully justified in hoping they can have one small platform on which they can post unscathed (I know they have representatives in media like OAN and Fox News, but I’m more talking about independent publishing, and they’re still far outnumbered anyway).
Yeah, man. I’m with you. And I think Katz’s point is serious, at its core, but I wish the point had been made by a journalist with more integrity. His position deserves better.
Fair enough, I don’t have the knowledge to speak to that. I’ve heard it said many times before; this current situation seems to me like a different level of it than usual. But I’m no expert on the topic.
“You shall put all of the males to the sword. You may, however, take as your booty the women, the children and the livestock, and everything in the town – all of its spoil – and enjoy the use of the spoil of your enemy which the Lord gives unto you.” — Deuteronomy 20:13
-
“The Messenger said, ‘If the disbelievers do not accept Islam, kill them, loot them and rape their women.’ And thus, advance Islam and strengthen Islam.” — Al-Bukhaari, Vol. 4, Book 54, Hadith 464
“Oh how fond they are of the book of Esther, which is so beautifully attuned to their bloodthirsty, vengeful, murderous yearning and hope.” — Martin Luther
Once the “Nazi” card is thrown on the table, the entire hand is spoiled. No need for evidence when appeals to emotion via buzzwords is the “progressive” way.
Cool. Two Newfies. You guys are nearly Canadian. (Just kidding..). I am born and live in BC. Also, nearly a Canadian. But less and less so for every year of Justin’s reign.
Pardonne mon français . . . Le judéo-messianisme répand parmi nous son message empoisonné depuis près de deux mille ans. Les universalismes démocratique et communiste sont récents, mais ils n’ont fait que renforcer le vieux récit juif. Ce sont les mêmes idéaux . . .
Les idéaux transnationaux, transraciaux, transsexuels, transculturels que ces idéologies nous prêchent (au-delà des peuples, des races, des cultures) et qui sont le subsistance quotidienne de nos écoles, dans nos médias, dans notre culture populaire, à nos universités, et sur nos rues, ont fini par réduire notre identité biosymbolique et notre fierté ethnique à leur expression minimale.
Le judaïsme, le christianisme, et l’islam sont des cultes de mort originaires du Moyen-Orient et totalement étrangers à l’Europe et à ses peuples.
On se demande parfois pourquoi la gauche européenne s’entend si bien avec les musulmans. Pourquoi un mouvement souvent ouvertement antireligieux prend-il le parti d’une religiosité farouche qui semble s’opposer à presque tout ce que la gauche a toujours prétendu défendre ? Une partie de l’explication réside dans le fait que l’Islam et le marxisme ont une racine idéologique commune : le judaïsme.
Don Rumsfeld avait raison lorsqu’il disait : «L’Europe s’est décalé sur son axe», c’est le mauvais côté qui a gagné la Seconde Guerre mondiale, et cela devient chaque jour plus clair . . . Qu’a fait l’OTAN pour défendre l’Europe? Absolument rien . . . Mes ennemis ne sont pas à Moscou, à Damas, à Téhéran, à Riyad ou dans quelque croque-mitaine teutonique éthéré, mes ennemis sont à Washington, Bruxelles et Tel Aviv . . . Nous socialistes nationaux est venu à libéré Paris, nous ne l'avons pas détruit.
Very cool! Newfies are the salt of the earth. Wonderful people. My mom is a Newfie. Many of my extended family still live there. I was up there last year. Are you in St John’s
I’m in Edmonton, but originally from Stephenville. Much of my family comes from Corner Brook, where my grand-aunt was mayor for several years, and my grand-uncle came from there. Your mom may know who he is. He was noteworthy for being a musician:
“You shall put all of the males to the sword. You may, however, take as your booty the women, the children and the livestock, and everything in the town – all of its spoil – and enjoy the use of the spoil of your enemy which the Lord gives unto you.” — Deuteronomy 20:13
-
“The Messenger said, ‘If the disbelievers do not accept Islam, kill them, loot them and rape their women.’ And thus, advance Islam and strengthen Islam.” — Al-Bukhaari, Vol. 4, Book 54, Hadith 464
IMHO, you give Katz too much credit. He works for THE ATLANTIC. That's all I need to know. He would never have gotten a job there unless he supported the US Empire narrative without ever questioning it. IOW, he's a paid propagandist, in this case coming in to try to disrupt a platform that allows opinions he doesn't like. That's all this is.
We can't afford healthcare for American children because we need to keep bombing everyone else's for the love of Jesus and Israel . . . Every year the USA gives away an $8,000.00 health insurance deductible for every natural born U.S. man, woman, and child, just to Israel alone . . .
Israel was just given $20 billion . . . It would cost $20 billion to build apartments for every homeless person in America to live in until they died, and the traitors in Washington D.C. sent ten times that to the cross-dressing gay satanist Israeli operative Volodymyr Zelensky in Ukraine . . .
So....Katz just gave all these people the gift of a ton of exposure ( free advertising if you will). He took them out of obscurity and out them in the limelight. Well done/sarcasm. 🙄
“You shall put all of the males to the sword. You may, however, take as your booty the women, the children and the livestock, and everything in the town – all of its spoil – and enjoy the use of the spoil of your enemy which the Lord gives unto you.” — Deuteronomy 20:13
-
“The Messenger said, ‘If the disbelievers do not accept Islam, kill them, loot them and rape their women.’ And thus, advance Islam and strengthen Islam.” — Al-Bukhaari, Vol. 4, Book 54, Hadith 464
How does a Jew get to Heaven from dry humping the Wailing Wall like Miley Cyrus?
Enquiring minds would like to know, so let’s ask Brother Nathaniel:
Jews go to the Wailing Wall and thrust their hips to imitate having intercourse with their “shekinah” (a female demon) while praying to their devil . . . at an old Roman fortress called Antonia . . .
Agree with some of the other comments on here. It is not sloppiness. It’s a baseless and intentional attack meant to subject this platform to mandatory ideological uniformity. Not negligence, but malice. Other than the fault, and it is barely that, of granting this man more presumption of decency then he deserves, this is all spot on. Good post.
How does a Jew get to Heaven from dry humping the Wailing Wall like Miley Cyrus?
Enquiring minds would like to know, so let’s ask Brother Nathaniel:
Jews go to the Wailing Wall and thrust their hips to imitate having intercourse with their “shekinah” (a female demon) while praying to their devil . . . at an old Roman fortress called Antonia . . .
Well done. The only thing Katz seems to have succeeded in is empowering progressive trolls, of which I am seeing more of, and encouraging softies to ban the "nazis" who question them. But I suppose too he pissed off a lot of solid people who are now more proactive about protecting Substack.
Sweden: Jews Call for Ban on Nordic Resistance Movement . . .
❝I ALWAYS LIKE to take note of Jewish organisations calling for bans on immigration resistance parties. You could say “Why bother? We’re surrounded by Jews screeching for White Genocide in various, usually artfully disguised, ways. This is just another twig on the bonfire.”
This is true. But arguments about the JQ and its relationship to White minoritization are open to various kinds of objection. You can quote this or that Jewish journalist calling for open borders or abolishing White people. Objection? “It’s just one guy; no proof he’s representative of anything other than himself; besides, he’s making a legitimate argument that’s open to democratic debate.”
That is why calls for bans on political parties assume a special moral significance. It’s a demand for the suppression of debate. And when it comes from an organization that claims to be representative of Jewry, and that claim goes unchallenged, then a special moral culpability attaches to the Jews.❞
Sweden: Jews Call for Ban on Nordic Resistance Movement . . .
❝I ALWAYS LIKE to take note of Jewish organisations calling for bans on immigration resistance parties. You could say “Why bother? We’re surrounded by Jews screeching for White Genocide in various, usually artfully disguised, ways. This is just another twig on the bonfire.”
This is true. But arguments about the JQ and its relationship to White minoritization are open to various kinds of objection. You can quote this or that Jewish journalist calling for open borders or abolishing White people. Objection? “It’s just one guy; no proof he’s representative of anything other than himself; besides, he’s making a legitimate argument that’s open to democratic debate.”
That is why calls for bans on political parties assume a special moral significance. It’s a demand for the suppression of debate. And when it comes from an organization that claims to be representative of Jewry, and that claim goes unchallenged, then a special moral culpability attaches to the Jews.❞
Have been thinking a lot about the value difference between reporting and opinion lately. Thanks for doing the work of actually looking at what's being talked about.
[26] The fairies are not to be seized on, and brought to answer for the hurt they do. So also the ecclesiastics vanish away from the tribunals of civil justice.
[27] The ecclesiastics take from young men the use of reason, by certain charms compounded of metaphysics, and miracles, and traditions, and abused Scripture, whereby they are good for nothing else but to execute what they command them. The fairies likewise are said to take young children out of their cradles, and to change them into natural fools, which common people do therefore call elves, and are apt to mischief.
[28] In what shop or operatory the fairies make their enchantment, the old wives have not determined. But the operatories of the clergy are well enough known to be the universities, that received their discipline from authority pontifical.
[29] When the fairies are displeased with anybody, they are said to send their elves to pinch them. The ecclesiastics, when they are displeased with any civil state, make also their elves, that is, superstitious, enchanted subjects, to pinch their princes, by preaching sedition; or one prince, enchanted with promises, to pinch another.
[30] The fairies marry not; but there be amongst them incubi that have copulation with flesh and blood. The priests also marry not.
-
Hobbes, Thomas. Leviathan: with selected variants from the Latin edition of 1668. Ed. Edwin Curley. Indianapolis: Hackett, 1994 . . . Leviathan: Part IV. Of the Kingdom of Darkness . . . Chap. xlvii. Of the Benefit that proceedeth from such Darkness, and to Whom it Accrueth . . . https://cwspangle.substack.com/p/leviathan-part-iv-of-the-kingdom
Katz is trash, already had one of his ilk take a quote of mine, and try to have it lead to an argument over my skin colour and when I revealed I'm not really white he proceeded to attack all white people. Honestly Katz and his ilk are disgusting, they are the real Nazis.
Though, this accusation, back away then whine shrilly for no reason, has given me an idea for a villain for one of my serial novels (I'm writing a bunch of them). I'm thinking an inquisitor who is a coward but keen to dole out punishment onto others, or a 'vizier' cast in that likeness.
Frankly, sick of these cancel-pigs stalking the internet, making life intolerable for others and poisoning fiction and hounding those of us who just want to write, discuss and otherwise compose.
Frankly the Establishment-pigs like Katz who believe themselves above all others, have no place in civilised society in my view. I don't wish them dead, only for them to go away and leave Substack. But I know that'll never happen. Excellent article Mr. Nolan am very impressed you poured a great deal of time and energy into this, and I salute your efforts.
We can't afford healthcare for American children because we need to keep bombing everyone else's for the love of Jesus and Israel . . . Every year the USA gives away an $8,000.00 health insurance deductible for every natural born U.S. man, woman, and child, just to Israel alone . . .
Israel was just given $20 billion . . . It would cost $20 billion to build apartments for every homeless person in America to live in until they died, and the traitors in Washington D.C. sent ten times that to the cross-dressing gay satanist Israeli operative Volodymyr Zelensky in Ukraine . . .
a person who is obstinately or unreasonably attached to a belief, opinion, or faction, especially one who is prejudiced against or antagonistic toward a person or people on the basis of their membership of a particular group.
Prejudice:
2
a(1)
: preconceived judgment or opinion
(2)
: an adverse opinion or leaning formed without just grounds or before sufficient knowledge
b
: an instance of such judgment or opinion
c
: an irrational attitude of hostility directed against an individual, a group, a race, or their supposed characteristics
When people hold prejudicial attitudes toward others of a certain group, they tend to view everyone with the defining characteristic as the same. They paint every individual with the trait with a broad brush and fail to look at each person as a unique individual. Keep reading to learn more about prejudice and how to reduce prejudice.
Describes Katz perfectly. He lumps everybody that does not follow his idea/definition as a Nazi.
It's time Katz be called what he is. He is a bigot, and has prejudice leanings. All off us that are against his fascistic censorship ideas are now Nazi supporters
You ask: "so what could his motive be? It’s hard to say, but a common theme among his examples is that they appear critical of progressive initiatives."
I don't believe his target/s were the writers he listed, but rather the Substack platform itself. Or rather, ANY platform that takes a stand for freedom of speech. We've witnessed over the past few years that there are individuals, corporations, government entities, etc. who have a strong interest in there NOT being places where people can freely exchange ideas. Mainstream outlets such as the Atlantic feature among these entities. Any platform that sticks to its guns re: free speech is inevitably going to find itself in the crosshairs of these folks. This was entirely predictable, and it will happen again and again. More power to Hamish McKenzie et al, for not caving in to this cowardly, dishonest, and yes, sloppy, bullying.
This is JK's lame ass attempt to throw a spoke into Substack's wheels which are going to run over him and all his ilk until the truth about all these weasels come out, and they slink back into the holes they crawled out from.
How does a Jew get to Heaven from dry humping the Wailing Wall like Miley Cyrus?
Enquiring minds would like to know, so let’s ask Brother Nathaniel:
Jews go to the Wailing Wall and thrust their hips to imitate having intercourse with their “shekinah” (a female demon) while praying to their devil . . . at an old Roman fortress called Antonia . . .
"As I demonstrate below, Katz’s research is sloppy at best, and negligent at worst..."
This is incorrect, and dangerously so. Katz's "research" is not research, not sloppy, and not negligent. It is intentional gaslighting propaganda presented on behalf of the global Establishment in an effort to create a world in which there are no online spaces where wrongthink is allowed to flourish. He is a propagandist, not a researcher. His "research" is no more "sloppy" or "negligent" than is the "research" of Joseph Goebbels.
I don't know if he is a paid agent carrying out orders or just a fierce Establishment loyalist acting on his own volition, but he serves the same purpose either way. There is an army of these people with the self-righteousness and certitude of the Red Guard, and their objective is nothing less than the complete elimination of public dissent. There is no good faith explanation for the gaping chasm between Katz's argument and the evidence you quite skillfully present in this piece. These people do not deserve the benefit of any doubt. The overly charitable interpretation you give to Katz's propaganda efforts will not be reciprocated. The title should read "The Atlantic has a gaslighting and propaganda problem."
Other than that, great article.
There is an army of these people and its called Antifa.
There's also the campaign called Hasbara.
“They are, all of them, born with raging fanaticism in their hearts, just as the Bretons and the Germans are born with blonde hair, I would not be in the least bit surprised if these people would not become deadly to the human race. They have surpassed all nations in impertinent fables, in bad conduct and in barbarism. They deserve to be punished, for this is their destiny. The Jewish nation dares to display an irreconcilable hatred towards all nations, and revolts against all masters; always superstitious, always greedy for the well-being enjoyed by others, always barbarous; cringing in misfortune and insolent in prosperity.”
— François-Marie Voltaire
NSDAP started the Brownshirts to fight Antifa . . .
Outstanding work, Ian. More than I could dream of ever doing myself.
You’re too kind to me and too hard on yourself, Phisto. Deeply appreciated.
Well, someone has to cultivate my massive ego. 😝
-
“You shall put all of the males to the sword. You may, however, take as your booty the women, the children and the livestock, and everything in the town – all of its spoil – and enjoy the use of the spoil of your enemy which the Lord gives unto you.” — Deuteronomy 20:13
-
“The Messenger said, ‘If the disbelievers do not accept Islam, kill them, loot them and rape their women.’ And thus, advance Islam and strengthen Islam.” — Al-Bukhaari, Vol. 4, Book 54, Hadith 464
-
Ian-- nice work. I suspect that you and I aren’t literally in the same lane politically, but I point that out to make it clear that whatever the truth of that, tactics like JK’s shouldn’t be praised or admired. And I’m very impressed by the work you put into this.
My position, for what it’s worth-- there’s enough actual evidence for someone to be outraged about the platform, if they’re inclined. It’s far less than JK implies, and I do think innuendo is the right word here. I feel like he’s in the neighborhood of Roy Cohn here, a neighborhood I would prefer the left avoid entirely.
He seems now to be saying that he’s not actually arguing for kicking people off the platform at all, and possibly he means it. I’ll give him the benefit of the doubt that he doesn’t give to substack or Hanania.
But I’ve seen a lot of posts calling for people to be deplatformed, and while there’s a range of positions on that side, mostly I see people trying to thread a needle that can’t be threaded, like this: “this isn’t a free speech issue. Nazis shouldn’t have free speech.”
I don’t object to anyone leaving substack on principle over this; it seems to me that they could make that call with the actual true evidence rather than the gilded lily version JK offers. I hope they won’t leave over it, but if they do i wish them well. I respect people who make a principled stand, even if I don’t share their view. I don’t respect people who profit from grandstanding. He’s misled a lot of good people, as I see it.
He has said that he can’t afford to leave substack. So this means he’s smearing the substack people with undefended innuendo, while risking not one cent of the money he makes from their policies.
In the end, I assume a lot of people will get tired of beating this horse and get back to beating the horse I preferred to see beaten, the issue of antisemitism creeping into progressive orthodoxy. I don’t know if JK has condemned that; in my view that’s a real problem, and the Nazis-on-substack problem doesn’t compare.
Hey, Karl. Excellent analysis.
To be sure, there’s not much in the way of explicit calls to deplatform; that, I’ll give to Katz. And his basic premise is not badly founded, because he would find much succour among the Substack lay populace if it were teeming with Nazis.
But I find his case severely lacking, being full of holes such as it is; certainly not enough to warrant the scathing ad hominems he’s been throwing around with profligate impunity as well as the incessant badgering for the Substack brass to cede to his demand for a sit-down, which I’m sure he would not carry out honestly.
I’m not concerned at all with disagreements over politics; believe me. Just about everyone who has been giving me praise (and I thank them) for these posts is farther to the political right than I am, but at the same time, I sympathize with them, because at this moment in history, it’s the Left that are driving *them* into corners rather than the other way around, and a tired tactic I hear over and over is to associate libertarians and conservatives with Nazis, which is a low move.
Now, you can point to the much more murderous Communist regimes of Stalin, Mao, and Pol Pot (all of whom acted in a manner indistinguishable from despotism) as a like salvo against the political left (that would be just as wrong), but that fails to work for one reason: Communism isn’t associated with ethnic cleansing like Nazism.
I conclude from this that the critical left in the West thinks that identitarian concerns trump lives lost altogether, which calls into question why we let them dominate so many aspects of daily life, from media and entertainment to scholastics and PR to the virulent and voracious campaigns to mow down collateral under the overt auspices of “hunting down Nazis” while never answering questions about why they don’t go after more prominent threats.
In this sense, though I don’t agree with their policies, personally, I think conservatives are fully justified in hoping they can have one small platform on which they can post unscathed (I know they have representatives in media like OAN and Fox News, but I’m more talking about independent publishing, and they’re still far outnumbered anyway).
Yeah, man. I’m with you. And I think Katz’s point is serious, at its core, but I wish the point had been made by a journalist with more integrity. His position deserves better.
Pardonne mon français . . . Va te faire foutre toi et ton dieu juif . . .
https://cwspangle.substack.com/p/pardonne-mon-francais-va-te-faire
Thoughtful commentary. With which I take but one issue; “antisemitism creeping into progressive orthodoxy.”
It’s been there all along the murderous events of 10/7 have driven it into the open.
Fair enough, I don’t have the knowledge to speak to that. I’ve heard it said many times before; this current situation seems to me like a different level of it than usual. But I’m no expert on the topic.
-
“You shall put all of the males to the sword. You may, however, take as your booty the women, the children and the livestock, and everything in the town – all of its spoil – and enjoy the use of the spoil of your enemy which the Lord gives unto you.” — Deuteronomy 20:13
-
“The Messenger said, ‘If the disbelievers do not accept Islam, kill them, loot them and rape their women.’ And thus, advance Islam and strengthen Islam.” — Al-Bukhaari, Vol. 4, Book 54, Hadith 464
-
“Oh how fond they are of the book of Esther, which is so beautifully attuned to their bloodthirsty, vengeful, murderous yearning and hope.” — Martin Luther
https://cwspangle.substack.com/p/oh-how-fond-they-are-of-the-book
Once the “Nazi” card is thrown on the table, the entire hand is spoiled. No need for evidence when appeals to emotion via buzzwords is the “progressive” way.
I noticed that 'Nazi' is the leftist buzzword du jour. Reminds me of a middle school bully.
Are you seriously a Newfie? I am, too.
I enjoy your essays
Thanks, Mark!
Cool. Two Newfies. You guys are nearly Canadian. (Just kidding..). I am born and live in BC. Also, nearly a Canadian. But less and less so for every year of Justin’s reign.
Pardonne mon français . . . Le judéo-messianisme répand parmi nous son message empoisonné depuis près de deux mille ans. Les universalismes démocratique et communiste sont récents, mais ils n’ont fait que renforcer le vieux récit juif. Ce sont les mêmes idéaux . . .
Les idéaux transnationaux, transraciaux, transsexuels, transculturels que ces idéologies nous prêchent (au-delà des peuples, des races, des cultures) et qui sont le subsistance quotidienne de nos écoles, dans nos médias, dans notre culture populaire, à nos universités, et sur nos rues, ont fini par réduire notre identité biosymbolique et notre fierté ethnique à leur expression minimale.
Le judaïsme, le christianisme, et l’islam sont des cultes de mort originaires du Moyen-Orient et totalement étrangers à l’Europe et à ses peuples.
On se demande parfois pourquoi la gauche européenne s’entend si bien avec les musulmans. Pourquoi un mouvement souvent ouvertement antireligieux prend-il le parti d’une religiosité farouche qui semble s’opposer à presque tout ce que la gauche a toujours prétendu défendre ? Une partie de l’explication réside dans le fait que l’Islam et le marxisme ont une racine idéologique commune : le judaïsme.
Don Rumsfeld avait raison lorsqu’il disait : «L’Europe s’est décalé sur son axe», c’est le mauvais côté qui a gagné la Seconde Guerre mondiale, et cela devient chaque jour plus clair . . . Qu’a fait l’OTAN pour défendre l’Europe? Absolument rien . . . Mes ennemis ne sont pas à Moscou, à Damas, à Téhéran, à Riyad ou dans quelque croque-mitaine teutonique éthéré, mes ennemis sont à Washington, Bruxelles et Tel Aviv . . . Nous socialistes nationaux est venu à libéré Paris, nous ne l'avons pas détruit.
https://cwspangle.substack.com/p/pardonne-mon-francais-va-te-faire
Very cool! Newfies are the salt of the earth. Wonderful people. My mom is a Newfie. Many of my extended family still live there. I was up there last year. Are you in St John’s
I’m in Edmonton, but originally from Stephenville. Much of my family comes from Corner Brook, where my grand-aunt was mayor for several years, and my grand-uncle came from there. Your mom may know who he is. He was noteworthy for being a musician:
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dick_Nolan_(musician)
Cool! I've heard the name.
-
“You shall put all of the males to the sword. You may, however, take as your booty the women, the children and the livestock, and everything in the town – all of its spoil – and enjoy the use of the spoil of your enemy which the Lord gives unto you.” — Deuteronomy 20:13
-
“The Messenger said, ‘If the disbelievers do not accept Islam, kill them, loot them and rape their women.’ And thus, advance Islam and strengthen Islam.” — Al-Bukhaari, Vol. 4, Book 54, Hadith 464
-
IMHO, you give Katz too much credit. He works for THE ATLANTIC. That's all I need to know. He would never have gotten a job there unless he supported the US Empire narrative without ever questioning it. IOW, he's a paid propagandist, in this case coming in to try to disrupt a platform that allows opinions he doesn't like. That's all this is.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
We can't afford healthcare for American children because we need to keep bombing everyone else's for the love of Jesus and Israel . . . Every year the USA gives away an $8,000.00 health insurance deductible for every natural born U.S. man, woman, and child, just to Israel alone . . .
https://cwspangle.substack.com/p/oh-how-fond-they-are-of-the-book
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
Israel was just given $20 billion . . . It would cost $20 billion to build apartments for every homeless person in America to live in until they died, and the traitors in Washington D.C. sent ten times that to the cross-dressing gay satanist Israeli operative Volodymyr Zelensky in Ukraine . . .
https://cwspangle.substack.com/p/satanism-is-a-jewish-cult
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
So....Katz just gave all these people the gift of a ton of exposure ( free advertising if you will). He took them out of obscurity and out them in the limelight. Well done/sarcasm. 🙄
*put not out 😂
-
“You shall put all of the males to the sword. You may, however, take as your booty the women, the children and the livestock, and everything in the town – all of its spoil – and enjoy the use of the spoil of your enemy which the Lord gives unto you.” — Deuteronomy 20:13
-
“The Messenger said, ‘If the disbelievers do not accept Islam, kill them, loot them and rape their women.’ And thus, advance Islam and strengthen Islam.” — Al-Bukhaari, Vol. 4, Book 54, Hadith 464
-
Indeed. It's called the Streisand Effect.
How does a Jew get to Heaven from dry humping the Wailing Wall like Miley Cyrus?
Enquiring minds would like to know, so let’s ask Brother Nathaniel:
Jews go to the Wailing Wall and thrust their hips to imitate having intercourse with their “shekinah” (a female demon) while praying to their devil . . . at an old Roman fortress called Antonia . . .
https://cwspangle.substack.com/i/138320669/how-does-a-jew-get-to-heaven-from-dry-humping-the-wailing-wall-like-miley-cyrus
Agree with some of the other comments on here. It is not sloppiness. It’s a baseless and intentional attack meant to subject this platform to mandatory ideological uniformity. Not negligence, but malice. Other than the fault, and it is barely that, of granting this man more presumption of decency then he deserves, this is all spot on. Good post.
How does a Jew get to Heaven from dry humping the Wailing Wall like Miley Cyrus?
Enquiring minds would like to know, so let’s ask Brother Nathaniel:
Jews go to the Wailing Wall and thrust their hips to imitate having intercourse with their “shekinah” (a female demon) while praying to their devil . . . at an old Roman fortress called Antonia . . .
https://cwspangle.substack.com/i/138320669/how-does-a-jew-get-to-heaven-from-dry-humping-the-wailing-wall-like-miley-cyrus
Well done. The only thing Katz seems to have succeeded in is empowering progressive trolls, of which I am seeing more of, and encouraging softies to ban the "nazis" who question them. But I suppose too he pissed off a lot of solid people who are now more proactive about protecting Substack.
Sweden: Jews Call for Ban on Nordic Resistance Movement . . .
❝I ALWAYS LIKE to take note of Jewish organisations calling for bans on immigration resistance parties. You could say “Why bother? We’re surrounded by Jews screeching for White Genocide in various, usually artfully disguised, ways. This is just another twig on the bonfire.”
This is true. But arguments about the JQ and its relationship to White minoritization are open to various kinds of objection. You can quote this or that Jewish journalist calling for open borders or abolishing White people. Objection? “It’s just one guy; no proof he’s representative of anything other than himself; besides, he’s making a legitimate argument that’s open to democratic debate.”
That is why calls for bans on political parties assume a special moral significance. It’s a demand for the suppression of debate. And when it comes from an organization that claims to be representative of Jewry, and that claim goes unchallenged, then a special moral culpability attaches to the Jews.❞
https://nationalvanguard.org/2019/03/sweden-jews-call-for-ban-on-nordic-resistance-movement/
Just want to applaud starting a post about Nazis with “The furor...”
If intentional, fantastic work. If not, serendipity.
Serendipity, actually. Good eye.
Sweden: Jews Call for Ban on Nordic Resistance Movement . . .
❝I ALWAYS LIKE to take note of Jewish organisations calling for bans on immigration resistance parties. You could say “Why bother? We’re surrounded by Jews screeching for White Genocide in various, usually artfully disguised, ways. This is just another twig on the bonfire.”
This is true. But arguments about the JQ and its relationship to White minoritization are open to various kinds of objection. You can quote this or that Jewish journalist calling for open borders or abolishing White people. Objection? “It’s just one guy; no proof he’s representative of anything other than himself; besides, he’s making a legitimate argument that’s open to democratic debate.”
That is why calls for bans on political parties assume a special moral significance. It’s a demand for the suppression of debate. And when it comes from an organization that claims to be representative of Jewry, and that claim goes unchallenged, then a special moral culpability attaches to the Jews.❞
https://nationalvanguard.org/2019/03/sweden-jews-call-for-ban-on-nordic-resistance-movement/
Have been thinking a lot about the value difference between reporting and opinion lately. Thanks for doing the work of actually looking at what's being talked about.
To quote Judge Chamberlain Haller: “That is a lucid, intelligent, well thought-out objection...overruled.”
[26] The fairies are not to be seized on, and brought to answer for the hurt they do. So also the ecclesiastics vanish away from the tribunals of civil justice.
[27] The ecclesiastics take from young men the use of reason, by certain charms compounded of metaphysics, and miracles, and traditions, and abused Scripture, whereby they are good for nothing else but to execute what they command them. The fairies likewise are said to take young children out of their cradles, and to change them into natural fools, which common people do therefore call elves, and are apt to mischief.
[28] In what shop or operatory the fairies make their enchantment, the old wives have not determined. But the operatories of the clergy are well enough known to be the universities, that received their discipline from authority pontifical.
[29] When the fairies are displeased with anybody, they are said to send their elves to pinch them. The ecclesiastics, when they are displeased with any civil state, make also their elves, that is, superstitious, enchanted subjects, to pinch their princes, by preaching sedition; or one prince, enchanted with promises, to pinch another.
[30] The fairies marry not; but there be amongst them incubi that have copulation with flesh and blood. The priests also marry not.
-
Hobbes, Thomas. Leviathan: with selected variants from the Latin edition of 1668. Ed. Edwin Curley. Indianapolis: Hackett, 1994 . . . Leviathan: Part IV. Of the Kingdom of Darkness . . . Chap. xlvii. Of the Benefit that proceedeth from such Darkness, and to Whom it Accrueth . . . https://cwspangle.substack.com/p/leviathan-part-iv-of-the-kingdom
Great summary.
Katz is trash, already had one of his ilk take a quote of mine, and try to have it lead to an argument over my skin colour and when I revealed I'm not really white he proceeded to attack all white people. Honestly Katz and his ilk are disgusting, they are the real Nazis.
Though, this accusation, back away then whine shrilly for no reason, has given me an idea for a villain for one of my serial novels (I'm writing a bunch of them). I'm thinking an inquisitor who is a coward but keen to dole out punishment onto others, or a 'vizier' cast in that likeness.
Frankly, sick of these cancel-pigs stalking the internet, making life intolerable for others and poisoning fiction and hounding those of us who just want to write, discuss and otherwise compose.
Frankly the Establishment-pigs like Katz who believe themselves above all others, have no place in civilised society in my view. I don't wish them dead, only for them to go away and leave Substack. But I know that'll never happen. Excellent article Mr. Nolan am very impressed you poured a great deal of time and energy into this, and I salute your efforts.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
We can't afford healthcare for American children because we need to keep bombing everyone else's for the love of Jesus and Israel . . . Every year the USA gives away an $8,000.00 health insurance deductible for every natural born U.S. man, woman, and child, just to Israel alone . . .
https://cwspangle.substack.com/p/oh-how-fond-they-are-of-the-book
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
Israel was just given $20 billion . . . It would cost $20 billion to build apartments for every homeless person in America to live in until they died, and the traitors in Washington D.C. sent ten times that to the cross-dressing gay satanist Israeli operative Volodymyr Zelensky in Ukraine . . .
https://cwspangle.substack.com/p/satanism-is-a-jewish-cult
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
Bigot:
a person who is obstinately or unreasonably attached to a belief, opinion, or faction, especially one who is prejudiced against or antagonistic toward a person or people on the basis of their membership of a particular group.
Prejudice:
2
a(1)
: preconceived judgment or opinion
(2)
: an adverse opinion or leaning formed without just grounds or before sufficient knowledge
b
: an instance of such judgment or opinion
c
: an irrational attitude of hostility directed against an individual, a group, a race, or their supposed characteristics
When people hold prejudicial attitudes toward others of a certain group, they tend to view everyone with the defining characteristic as the same. They paint every individual with the trait with a broad brush and fail to look at each person as a unique individual. Keep reading to learn more about prejudice and how to reduce prejudice.
Describes Katz perfectly. He lumps everybody that does not follow his idea/definition as a Nazi.
It's time Katz be called what he is. He is a bigot, and has prejudice leanings. All off us that are against his fascistic censorship ideas are now Nazi supporters
Thank you for your hard work here!
You ask: "so what could his motive be? It’s hard to say, but a common theme among his examples is that they appear critical of progressive initiatives."
I don't believe his target/s were the writers he listed, but rather the Substack platform itself. Or rather, ANY platform that takes a stand for freedom of speech. We've witnessed over the past few years that there are individuals, corporations, government entities, etc. who have a strong interest in there NOT being places where people can freely exchange ideas. Mainstream outlets such as the Atlantic feature among these entities. Any platform that sticks to its guns re: free speech is inevitably going to find itself in the crosshairs of these folks. This was entirely predictable, and it will happen again and again. More power to Hamish McKenzie et al, for not caving in to this cowardly, dishonest, and yes, sloppy, bullying.
This is JK's lame ass attempt to throw a spoke into Substack's wheels which are going to run over him and all his ilk until the truth about all these weasels come out, and they slink back into the holes they crawled out from.
How does a Jew get to Heaven from dry humping the Wailing Wall like Miley Cyrus?
Enquiring minds would like to know, so let’s ask Brother Nathaniel:
Jews go to the Wailing Wall and thrust their hips to imitate having intercourse with their “shekinah” (a female demon) while praying to their devil . . . at an old Roman fortress called Antonia . . .
https://cwspangle.substack.com/i/138320669/how-does-a-jew-get-to-heaven-from-dry-humping-the-wailing-wall-like-miley-cyrus